Ate is the original brake manufacturer of most BMW's I think. I have the ATE slotted ones on my '85 318i and they worked great. The older 318's had the thinner rotors, not vented ones.
Two weeks ago I just installed a set of the Zimmerman cross drilled rotors and a set of PBR metal master pads. The rotors cost me $60 each from my local parts guy and the pads for $30 from him also. So I paid $150, I like this guy so I try to buy from him when I can.
I really like the zimmermans and the PBR's. Real smooth, nice feel, and no noise. I havent really gone out and heated the brakes up yet... but I am sure they will do well. I cannot really compare the ATE's to teh Zimmermans has 325 I drive now has vented rotors and the 318 did not. Plus the 318 was noticably lighter but it did not have ABS like my 325 does. They are both good in my opinion, and wont go wrong with either. I just think the cross drilled look cooler
.
Later