Well you don't win with either one, Leather is obviously more luxurious and comfortable, however Leatherette or VINYL tends to be tougher and you can clean it with a semi-wet cloth and soap. I have never owned a vinyl trimmed vehicle but I think it lasts longer to a point, leather tends to keep its mass but takes a lot of care, were as vinyl doesn’t keep its mass (when I say mass I mean how thick the actually covering stays). My take if you can’t afford a car loaded with Leather don’t buy it, that is why they offer vinyl.