Well, I made the decision and went with the Nokians. Hakkepeliita RSI. Price was $242 each Cdn, which was about $100 less per tire than the Michelin Pilot Alpins or any of the Blizzaks. The guys at the tire shop were universally adamant that I would love these tires, and friends of mine have been equally raving about the Hakkas.
The rims were a bit tricky to get, though. Apparently the bolt pattern is "5 X 120" which meant that only a select few rims would fit, and they would have to be ordered. So I went with basic steel rims and wheel covers. Even these wheels were $159 each. Looks kind of crappy, but here's the clincher. Today (that's right October 16th) we have almost a foot of wet snow on the ground. I went out for a short spin, and I can tell you that these tires on a RWD car are waaaaay better than any FWD set up I've ever had.
I'll keep you posted. I do consider myself a bit of an expert, having lived in western Canada my entire life, where winter is a good 6 months of the year. I'll be interested to see what happens in minus 30 with black ice.