winter tires

Messages
107
Likes
0
Location
Vancouver, B.C.
#1
I just put new winter tires on my 2000 323i w/ original 16" wheels. I always had 205/55/R16 tires, but the tire store only had 205/60/R16 in stock and said that they will be fine. Is that true? Has anyone done this?
 

Big Daddy

Senior Member
Messages
10,446
Likes
5
Location
PNW (Left) Coast
#2
That is not good and could affect your traction control system, what happens when you corner, is your light flashing? I did this once accidently with my roadster and it would not corner without flashing and retarding the throttle. The size tire they put on your car is 2.54 inches bigger in Circumference than your stock size.
 
Messages
112
Likes
0
Location
Concord, NH
#3
I don't believe it'll matter.

Big Daddy, only the width of the tire is different, no? They're both 16" so it shouldn't mess with the traction control.
 

Big Daddy

Senior Member
Messages
10,446
Likes
5
Location
PNW (Left) Coast
#4
Here are the demisions of the tire sizes listed by BMWCA:

205/55-16 sidewall- 4.4" Radius- 12.4" Diameter- 24.9" Circumference- 78.2" Revolutions- 811/mi Speedoemter- 60MPH Odometer- 10000mi N/A

205/60-16 sidewall- 4.8" Radius- 12.8" Diameter- 25.7" Circumference- 80.7" Revolutions- 785/mi Speedometer- 58MPH Odometer- 9686mi

Difference 3.2%

Circumference
The circumference of the tire.

Diameter
The diameter of the tire.

Difference
The percentage difference in size between the reference (first) tire and a subsequent tire.

Odometer
The reported odometer reading compared to the reference (first) tire. For example, if the reference tire is listed as 10000mi and a subsequent tire is listed as 9500mi, that means the subsequent tire will report 9500mi traveled when the vehicle actually traveled 10000mi.
Radius
The radius of the tire.

Revolutions
The number of times the tire rotates per mile or kilometer.

Sidewall
The sidewall height of the tire.

Specification
The tire specification as determined by the calculator.

Speedometer
The reported speedometer reading compared to the reference (first) tire. For example, if the reference tire is listed as 60MPH and a subsequent tire is listed as 55MPH, that means the subsequent tire will report 55MPH when the vehicle is actually traveling at 60MPH.
 
Messages
107
Likes
0
Location
Vancouver, B.C.
#5
Big Daddy, your correct, apparently the acceptable differece is 3% but these are 3.2%. I spoke with the manufacturer (Pirelli) and they do not support this and have contacted the retailer. They are replacing them with 55 in a couple of weeks. The retailer thinks that it's okay to have 60s but I'm not comfortable with them.
BTW, my traction control does not come on when cornering.
 
Messages
4,917
Likes
18
Location
Reading,PA
#6
It is OK as far as tire to rim fit is concerned, but the diameter difference is too much and is causing your problem as Dan said.

The retailer does not know what he is talking about. The retailer should be aware of the negative impact on ABS, traction control, flat tire monitoring computer systems, and brake pad/rotor heating. Brake pads and rotors are designed for a specific tire diameter specification. This is another factor in the 3% maximum recommendation.
 
Messages
107
Likes
0
Location
Vancouver, B.C.
#7
I want to return the tires for a full refund and take my business elsewhere. If they refuse (which they have before) it sounds like there's enough info out there that would help if I take them to small claims court! Pirelli does not agree to what they did and I'm sure BMW will also have supporting data.
Thanks all!
 


Top