not a tough decision for me
Lets see it's $1400 cheaper, it wears longer, it requires minimal upkeep, and most of the passengers think that it's real leather...hey it's your dough if you get jollies from having real leather go for it...for me I'll take leatherette every time!
My car is nearly four years old with 80K on the clock and I am ever so happy I bought leatherette...I actually agonized over the decision prior to ordering, but have rejoiced over the fact that I didn't spend extra money on something that I feel offers no value...but again I am one of those misguided folks who also only goes with BMW sched maintenance...80K and have never used a drop of oil!